How to Sell Your Firearms?
How to Sell Your Guns to Amherst Armory
Our process is simple, legal, and transparent. Here’s how it works:
Step 1: Ballpark Value
Look your firearm up on Gunbroker to get a ballpark.
Step 2: Stop By
Bring in your Valid Drivers License, Firearms, Box, Accessories, Documentation.
Step 3: Get Appraised
We inspect and appraise your gun to determine its fair market value.
Step 4: Choose Your Option
Pick instant cash (50% value) or consignment (80% when sold). Your choice!
Step 5: Get Paid
For buyouts, get paid immediately. For consignment, we call you when it sells.
Step 6: Legwork
We handle all legal paperwork, background checks, shipping.
Why Sell to Amherst Armory?
Fully Licensed FFL
We’re a licensed FFL and Class III dealer in Ohio, handling all transactions legally and professionally.
Fair Market Pricing
We base our offers on real market data from GunBroker and current demand, not lowball tactics.
No Hidden Fees
Our pricing is transparent: 50% instant cash or 80% consignment. No surprises, no fine print.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are you a licensed FFL dealer?
Yes. Amherst Armory is a fully licensed Federal Firearms License (FFL) and Class III dealer in Amherst, Ohio. We handle all transfers, background checks, and legal documentation for firearm sales.
What types of firearms do you buy?
We buy handguns, rifles, and shotguns in good working condition. We also handle NFA items, like Suppressors, SBRs, SBS, and AOW.
Do I need to bring anything besides the gun?
Yes — bring a valid Ohio driver’s license. If you have the original box, manuals, extra magazines, or accessories, those can increase the value.
How long does consignment take?
It depends on the firearm and market demand. Popular models in good condition often sell within weeks. We actively promote consignment guns online and in-store.
Can I sell inherited or estate firearms?
Yes! We help families handle estate gun sales all the time. Bring valid ID and we’ll walk you through the legal process for transferring inherited firearms.
What if my gun isn’t worth $500 for consignment?
No problem — we’ll still make you an instant cash offer at 50% of market value. You get paid today, no waiting.
What are the fees for unsold consignment items?
If your firearm does not sell and you choose to pick it up, there is a $50 fee per item to cover our listing costs and transfer processing.
Ready to Sell Your Firearms?
Visit us today or call for more information about selling or consigning your used guns.
Store Contact Info
Amherst Arms, LLC
1927 Cooper Foster Park Rd
Amherst, OH 44001
Located in the Tractor Supply Plaza, behind Arby’s
Phone: (440) 210-7979
Store Hours
| Monday | 4:00 – 7:00 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4:00 – 7:00 PM |
| Thursday | 4:00 – 7:00 PM |
| Friday | 12:00 PM – 2:00 PM 4:00 PM – 7:00 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |